Pilgrim Coffee Company

Pilgrim Coffee Company is a family-owned coffeehouse located at 12643 Metcalf Ave in Overland Park, Kansas, founded in January 2018 by three families — Bud and Nancy Tollie, Chip and Mary Tollie, and Jeff and Lesilee Stevens — all Johnson County locals with deep ties to the Kansas City coffee community. The shop serves a carefully curated menu of espresso drinks, pour overs, lattes, and teas, using beans roasted by Post Coffee Co. in Lee’s Summit and house-made syrups crafted from scratch. With a spacious, welcoming interior that includes a reservable private meeting room, Pilgrim Coffee has become a beloved neighborhood gathering spot built on a philosophy of quality coffee, friendly service, and genuine community connection.